Pricing · Oct 26, 2026 · 11 min read

Spec work: what to offer a client who asks for free concepts.

The useful answer to a request for free concepts is a small paid stage with its own price, its own dates and a credit against the full project if the client goes ahead, because a refusal on its own gives the prospect nothing to say yes to.

Spec work, short for speculative work, is design work a prospect asks for before they've agreed to pay for it, usually a few logo ideas or a homepage mock-up so they can decide which agency to hire. Most designers and design agencies refuse it, and they're right to, but a refusal on its own leaves the prospect with nothing to say yes to. The better answer is a short paid concept stage with its own price and dates, credited against the full project if the client goes ahead.

Take one request as the running example. A four-person brand and packaging agency in Savannah, Georgia, bills $115 an hour. On Tuesday, January 5, 2027, Lena Okafor, co-founder of Tidewell Kombucha, a small brewery in the same city that's about to put six flavors into regional grocery stores, emailed three agencies asking each of them for two or three logo ideas by Friday, January 15, so she could choose who would handle the new identity and the can labels.

What is spec work?

Spec work is creative work done for a prospective client before there's any agreement to pay for it, in the hope of being hired if they like it. AIGA, the professional association for design in the US, described it in 2009 as work done before engagement with a client and in anticipation of being paid if selected, and it encouraged designers to take on projects with full engagement instead. Copywriters say they write on spec when they draft sample ads nobody has commissioned, often to fill a portfolio.

The request comes in a few familiar shapes. A prospect asks several agencies for sample concepts and picks one, a company runs an open contest where only the winning design gets paid, or a hiring manager sets a take-home design test. Bonsai's guide, published in January 2026, lists contests, bidding on work, agency pitches and take-home assignments as forms of it, and separates it from volunteer work, pro bono work and internships, where nobody expects to be paid in the first place. What makes it spec work is that the client gets to see the thinking before deciding whether to pay for it.

Why do most agencies refuse to do spec work?

Most agencies refuse it because it's the most expensive way to sell a project, and the work it produces is usually worse than what a paid project would get. Doing what Lena asked would have taken the Savannah agency about 18 hours, three rough logo directions at roughly six hours each, which is $2,070 of time at $115 an hour given away on a one-in-three chance of winning. An agency that agrees to three requests like that every quarter has given away more than a month of one designer's billable time by the end of the year, and the projects it wins end up paying for the ones it lost.

The quality problem is just as real. Free concepts get drawn without a workshop, without a brief and without anyone on the client's side saying what the brand has to do, so the prospect ends up choosing between three guesses. Evok, an advertising agency that wrote against spec work in 2011, lists unoriginal ideas, thin research and the risk of trademark trouble among the costs to the client, and SodaPop Media's 2015 piece adds that a free job always slips behind the paid ones in the queue. A logo chosen that way also tends to come back for changes in the first week of the real project, because nobody tested it against anything.

Spec work also blurs who owns what. A prospect who receives three logo ideas and then hires a cheaper agency still has the files in their inbox, and an agency that finds its idea on a can six months later has very little to point to, since nothing was signed when the files were sent.

Is spec work ever worth doing?

It's rarely worth it for an agency, and only when the work stays yours or you've chosen to give it away. Pro bono work for a cause you'd support anyway isn't really spec work, because there's no hidden hope of payment, and SodaPop Media's piece makes volunteering its one exception. A self-initiated project for your own portfolio is also fine, since nobody else owns the result and you decide what it's for, which is why copywriters often write spec ads for brands they'd like to work with.

Open contests and crowdsourcing are the worst version, because dozens of designers do the work and one of them gets paid. A pitch for a large account is the case agencies argue about most, and Bonsai counts agency pitches among its forms of spec work. If you take part in one, treat it as a sales cost with a budget, decide in advance how many hours you'll spend on the chance of winning, and keep a record of those hours, because the decision should get harder each time you do the sums.

What can you offer a client instead of free concepts?

Offer them a short paid stage that does the thinking free concepts skip, priced up front and credited in full against the project if they hire you within a set period. It answers the prospect's real question, which is whether you're the right agency, with something better than a guess, and it costs them a small share of the project to find out. Most of the guides we read for this piece tell you to say no and stop there. Bonsai's suggestion to break the work into phases with payment at the end of each comes closest, but it doesn't put a price on the first phase or say what happens to it if the client walks away.

The Savannah agency replied to Lena on Wednesday, January 6, with what it calls a concept sprint, a fixed-price stage in four parts:

The reply said plainly that the agency doesn't send unpaid concepts, explained in two sentences that logos drawn without a brief are guesses, and then put the sprint, its price and its dates in the same email, so Lena had something real to weigh against the free logos the other two agencies would send. It didn't argue with her request or lecture her about the industry. Our piece on the branding process explains why a signed strategy page should come before any logo, and the sprint is that same order of work, sold before the full project rather than inside it.

How do you price a paid concept stage?

Price it from your own hourly rate and the hours it really takes, then credit the whole amount against the project so a client who hires you pays nothing extra for it. The sprint comes to 26 hours, which at $115 an hour is $2,990, paid before the workshop, and the agency's offer said the full $2,990 would come off the project fee if Tidewell signed within 30 days of the presentation.

Lena paid on Monday, January 11, the workshop ran on Wednesday the 13th, Tidewell signed the strategy page on Friday the 15th, and the two routes were presented on Friday, January 22. She chose route B, a hand-lettered wordmark with a small wave under the T, and signed the full project on Tuesday, January 26. That project was priced at $24,150 for 210 hours: the sprint's 26 hours, 40 hours of identity refinement ($4,600), six can labels at 14 hours each ($9,660), 30 hours of brand guidelines ($3,450) and 30 hours of production files and printer proofs ($3,450). With the credit applied, $21,160 was left to invoice. The other two agencies sent free logos by the Friday deadline, which left Lena comparing drawings on taste, while the sprint gave her a strategy she had signed and two routes measured against it.

Two things keep the price fair. The sprint should be small enough that saying yes is easy, which on a project this size means a little over a tenth of the fee, and here it's 12.4% of $24,150. It also has to be complete in itself, so a client who pays and then goes elsewhere still leaves with a signed strategy and two developed routes to look at, which is more than any free round of logos would have given them. If you're still working out what your hours should cost, our piece on graphic design pricing builds the rate up from what an agency costs to run.

Who owns the concepts if the client doesn't hire you?

The client should own whatever they paid to keep, and nothing else, and the offer should say which is which before any money changes hands. The Savannah agency's offer gave Tidewell the strategy page outright once the sprint was paid, since the brewery could hand that page to any designer, and kept both logo routes as the agency's property unless Tidewell hired it to finish one. If Tidewell had walked away, it could have taken the strategy to another agency, but neither route.

That split follows the same logic as a finished project, where the client owns the final artwork once it's paid for and the agency keeps the routes that weren't chosen, and it's the same rule our article on the kill fee applies to a project that stops partway. Whether a clause like this holds up depends on where you and the client are, so have a lawyer read the wording before it goes into your standard offer. Writing it down at least means the question is answered in a document the client agreed to, rather than in an argument about files that went out with no terms attached.

What do you do when an existing client asks for free concepts?

Treat it as a change request with its own price, because it's the same unpaid work coming from a client who has already signed. It usually arrives as a small favor, a quick look at an idea before anyone commits to it, and it's easy to agree to when you're already working with the person asking.

On Thursday, February 25, about a month into the project, Lena asked for a quick mock-up of a seventh label for a winter flavor, so the brewery could decide whether to add it to the spring order. The agency priced the mock-up at 7 hours, or $805, with the same credit rule as the sprint: if Tidewell added the flavor, the $805 would count toward the full label at 14 hours, or $1,610, leaving another $805 to pay. Lena approved it the same day, the brewery added the flavor in March, and the project went to $25,760 without the agency spending an hour it wasn't paid for.

A request like that is easier to price when the client already knows the route for it. The agency logged Lena's request in Docket, which sent the $805 figure to her as the named approver and kept her approval with its date beside the earlier sign-offs, and a standing change request form does the same job on paper. A favor with a price attached is a decision the client makes for themselves, while a favor without one is a cost the agency quietly absorbs.

The $2,990 that turned a free request into a first invoice

The figure that changed Lena's request was the $2,990 sprint, credited in full against the project, because it gave her a way to test the agency that cost her nothing if she turned out to be right about it. Free logos would have cost the Savannah agency $2,070 of time with a two-in-three chance of losing it, and the sprint turned the same week into paid work with a signed strategy at the end of it.

So keep one paid first stage ready for each kind of project you sell, with its hours, its price, its credit window and its ownership rule written down, and send it the same day a prospect asks for free work. The same stage can sit as the opening line of a graphic design proposal, so a client who reads the full fee also sees the smaller way in.

Frequently asked questions

What is spec work?

Spec work, short for speculative work, is creative work done for a prospective client before they've agreed to pay for it, in the hope of being hired. Typical examples are sample logos sent to win a project, entries in a design contest where only the winner gets paid, and unpaid take-home design tests.

Is spec work bad for a design agency?

For an agency it's usually a poor trade. Free concepts are drawn without a brief or a workshop, the time is given away on a small chance of winning, and nothing settles who owns the ideas afterward. Pro bono work for a cause and self-initiated portfolio pieces are different, since nobody is expecting to be paid for them.

What does working on spec mean?

Working on spec means doing the work first and getting paid only if the client decides to accept it. Copywriters use the phrase for sample ads written without a commission, and designers use it for concepts sent to a prospect in the hope of winning the project.

How do you say no to spec work without losing the client?

Decline in a sentence, explain briefly that concepts drawn without a brief are guesses, and offer a paid alternative in the same email with its price and its dates. In this article's example the alternative was a $2,990 concept sprint, credited in full against the project if the client signed within 30 days.

Should a paid concept stage be credited against the project?

Yes, if you want it to be an easy yes. With a credit, a client who hires you pays nothing extra for the stage, while a client who goes elsewhere still pays for the time and keeps whatever the offer said the stage would hand over.

Is an agency pitch a form of spec work?

Bonsai counts agency pitches among the forms of spec work when the agency produces creative ideas without being paid for them. Some agencies take part anyway as a cost of selling, and the sensible way to do that is with a fixed budget of hours decided before the pitch starts.

About the numbers The Savannah agency, Tidewell Kombucha, the $115 rate and every hour, date and total built from them are illustrative and in US dollars. The AIGA description is as CreativePro reported it in May 2009, and the points from Bonsai (January 2026), Evok (2011) and SodaPop Media (2015) are as those sources published them.